Skip to content

25% off photo and holiday greeting cards with code happy 26 (ends 10/20)

25% off photo and holiday greeting cards with code happy 26 (ends 10/20)

Shop
Shop
Gift Card
On Paper Press

Account

Ohio Postcards
Greeting Cards
Stationery
Arts + Crafts
- Calligraphy Supplies
- Art Supplies
Stamps + Sealing Wax + Embossers
Pens
Pencils
- Mechanical Pencils
Ink, Erasers + Other Accessories

Planners + Calendars
Notebooks + Journals
Personalized Items
Office Supplies

Posters, Prints + Art

All Things Ohio
Home + Gifts
- Jewelry

Ohio Postcards

Ohio Postcards

Shop
Gift Card
On Paper Press

Cute Mothman Introvert Birthday Card

Cute Mothman Introvert Birthday Card

$ 6.50

Skip to product information

Cute Mothman Introvert Birthday Card

Cute Mothman Introvert Birthday Card

Cute Mothman Introvert Birthday Card

$ 6.50

Shipping calculated at checkout.

Details

You might also like...

Product title

Product title

$ 19.99

NEWSLETTER

Email

FAQ

What forms of payment are accepted?

We gladly accept cash, debit and credit
Credit cards incur a 3% fee to partially offset processing expenses
All transactions incur 1% community reinvestment that supports the Short North Arts District
Receipts can be sent to email or phone but not printed

Payment methods

Are any items final sale?

paper (card stock, envelopes, posters/maps and frame kits, gift wrap)
fountain pens*
ink (bottled, refill, cartridges, etc.)
pencils with used erasers
typewriters*
antiques
personalized products (stationery, custom wax seals, embossers, self-inking stamps, etc.).

*While we won’t take these items back, we may be able to service them for you, whether they were purchased from us or not. On Paper reserves the right to deny refund(s) or exchange requests if the product is deemed used or opened.

What is the return policy?

Many items may be returned or exchanged within 30 days of purchase with the sales receipt or credit card information used to make the purchase. Items must be in working condition and unopened in their original packaging to qualify for a refund.

Where can I park?

Park in one of the participating garages in the Short North Arts District and pay only $1 for the first two hours between 9:00pm to 5:00pm.

Participating Garages:

The Castle: 965 N. High St
The Joseph: 53 W Russell St
Lincoln at Pearl: 40 E Lincoln St (one block from the shop)

On Paper
743 N. High Street
Columbus, Ohio 43215
(614) 424-6617
info@ONPAPER.COM

12:00 pm – 5:00 pm Sunday & Monday
11:00 am – 6:00 pm Tuesday – Saturday

© 2026 On Paper, Powered by Shopify

Refund policy
Privacy policy
Terms of service
Shipping policy

Your cart is empty

Have an account? Log in to check out faster.

Continue shopping

Search

Search

Products

"Happy Birthday" Your Cake Fell Off Birthday Card

"Happy Birthday" Your Cake Fell Off Birthday Card

$ 7.50
"I'm Proud" Greeting Card

"I'm Proud" Greeting Card

$ 8.50
"I'm So Glad" Greeting Card

"I'm So Glad" Greeting Card

$ 8.50
"No" Greeting Card

"No" Greeting Card

$ 7.75